Just a word of caution... this site has a VERY strict policy about the issue of "Name and Shame" - which we will shut down immediately... It is just too subject to the possibility of manipulation and abuse. And this idea of a public "Name and Fame" gets a little too close to that concept for my liking - there is the strong possibility that some unscrupulous member could start "shaming" instead...
The verification facility IS well suited to what you are looking for. And more people should make use of it. Request people that you have met to verify you if you believe they will give you a good reference, and verify others! And then contact the verifiers through a private mail to check if you want a reference to someone's character or ability. That way it stays out of the public arena... And accept that different people have different tastes, and maybe different standards against which to critique their playmates... At the end of the day, nothing beats a preliminary "meet and greet" and a good chat over a cappuccino or a cold beer / glass of wine, to enable you to assess the likelihood of compatibility.